[WWI] Voss D.III on floats

[John Huggins]

Lance,
I agree with the others who have commented on the judging.  If the  
model was not moved into the "What if" category, then I would judge  
it in the category it was entered into.  The only time accuracy would  
come into play would be if there was a tie and that was the only  
factor that was available to break the tie.

Unfortunately, the accuracy factor is not a major player is because  
to be used, each judge would have to be an expert on each type  
entered, which most of us are not.  In most cases, we are not even  
that much of an expert about most of the kits we build.
*
On May 31, 2006, at 12:25 PM, Lance Krieg wrote:

> This is an interesting item, and prompts me to ask those of you who
> judge at contests:
>
> Would the wildly incorrect combination of camouflage and markings
> affect how the plane was judged in the contest?  It seems well-enough
> made.
>
> I'm not sure that I could separate "accuracy" from "construction" far
> enough to countenance this combination, but perhaps that is why I  
> do not
> judge.  I'll be interested in hearing from those of you who DO  
> judge in
> contests around the world.
>
> Lance